- Published on
Flowers in a Pool of Blood: Thoughts From an American in Paris
They closed the Eiffel Tower.
Everything else here in Paris is closed too, but when the most widely recognized manmade structure and most visited monument in the entire world is completely shut down for three days, well, that's when you know this event and the lives it destroyed aren't just another blip in the news cycle.
I see tourists wandering about in a confused daze, with nowhere to go. Locals congregate in groups familiar and new, filling up the still-open cafes (nothing could ever close down the cafes in Paris!).
But they are talking differently now.
The tones are hushed, raw, somber, torn. Laughter has been replaced with silence. These are grown men now, with red eyes, ugly from crying but who cares, tears running down their stubble as they point at blood on the ground. You hear the question in every heaving sigh: when did the world stop making sense?
The date will be remembered as its own noun. The names of the concert hall, the restaurants, and stadium will forever shift in meaning, something sinister about them now, sounds which carry the weight of lost years.
Although 9/11 took place in two locations, its focus on the Towers have led us to conceive of it as primarily taking place in one part of New York. Friday Night, however, happened all over Paris. It feels different, here on the ground. The multiplicity of attacks makes it feel like everyone was close, was there, is hurting, knew somebody.
I was four blocks away, at a laundromat, oblivious. I folded my clothes and took the short way home (the other route I sometimes take would've put me three blocks away). For some reason I felt like turning in early that night. Now at my hostel, also four blocks away, I sat on the floor and made pleasant conversation with my hostel-mate, a recent graduate from Taijung on a solo traveling adventure. She and I talked of careers, possibilities, pleasing others, customs, travel.
Four blocks away in exactly the same moments, nineteen people were murdered in two adjacent restaurants while probably having similar conversations. An unknown further number were injured or hospitalized.
What staggers me into bafflement is that the universe has space for these two completely different worlds to be happening simultaneously, in almost exactly the same place. I hardly know what to think. I'm reminded of Joyce's description of the sky as a "vast, indifferent dome," always there, forever silent.
I learned of the events early the following morning when the night-shift receptionist wouldn't allow me outside, as per the instructions of the television. There was no functioning bus or Metro currently, and impromptu refugee encampments had been set up around the city for the millions who couldn't make it home. After an hour I convinced the night guard to let me outside, and I went immediately to the intersection of Rue Bichat and Rue Alibert.
Initial reports state that only those at Le Petit Cambodge, a restaurant, were affected; that is incorrect. Le Carillon, the bar across the street, is just as rent with bullet holes and shattered glass. I arrived before police or news did. Sawdust had been laid down over the square to absorb the blood. There was punctured concrete from bullet strafing throughout the entire intersection, and splintered bicycles and motorcycles from the same. Blood pooled on the entry steps to Le Carillon, some of it gristly with the remains of flesh, elsewhere leaking into the crevices and gutters before anyone could bring flowers. It was still wet when I got there.
I was part of a very small group of strangers, and as light came to the morning so did more and more people, with their silences, roses, candles, cameras and consternation. We staggered around each other, stupid and raw. No matter what we did, or where we looked, at the evidence of violent death, at the spaces between each other, up to the unblinking sky... what was the name of this thing that had happened here, just a few hours ago?
Death disorients us because it is enormous. We're so good at focusing on what is small in life. This has significant and obvious dangers (not being thankful, namely), but I wonder if this tendency carries a silver lining. For it is only because of our amazing ability to forget how near death always is that we get anything done in life.
We get up in the morning and throw ourselves into matters of varying importance. We have some unique sense which lets us forget about imminent mortality as we continue the Search, the Great Search for happiness and meaning, the quest in which we do the dumbest and the smartest of things, feeling our way in the dark towards the answers.
Because the successes we find along the way are worth it, whether we live another hour, or for a hundred years.
---
Also: I was woken up this morning by none other than CNN, calling on behalf of my friends and family, asking if I was alive and unharmed. I am. Thank you ever so much for such an outpouring of concern. It means a tremendous deal. My heart goes out to- well, everyone, but especially those were happy before Friday Night, and cannot be now.
Information on the events and some of what we've been going through here.
---
Thoughts on the same, with hindsight: Paris, One Year Later: A Personal Perspective
Photographs of mine in the hours and days afterward: Death in Paris
Everything else here in Paris is closed too, but when the most widely recognized manmade structure and most visited monument in the entire world is completely shut down for three days, well, that's when you know this event and the lives it destroyed aren't just another blip in the news cycle.
I see tourists wandering about in a confused daze, with nowhere to go. Locals congregate in groups familiar and new, filling up the still-open cafes (nothing could ever close down the cafes in Paris!).
But they are talking differently now.
The tones are hushed, raw, somber, torn. Laughter has been replaced with silence. These are grown men now, with red eyes, ugly from crying but who cares, tears running down their stubble as they point at blood on the ground. You hear the question in every heaving sigh: when did the world stop making sense?
The date will be remembered as its own noun. The names of the concert hall, the restaurants, and stadium will forever shift in meaning, something sinister about them now, sounds which carry the weight of lost years.
Although 9/11 took place in two locations, its focus on the Towers have led us to conceive of it as primarily taking place in one part of New York. Friday Night, however, happened all over Paris. It feels different, here on the ground. The multiplicity of attacks makes it feel like everyone was close, was there, is hurting, knew somebody.
I was four blocks away, at a laundromat, oblivious. I folded my clothes and took the short way home (the other route I sometimes take would've put me three blocks away). For some reason I felt like turning in early that night. Now at my hostel, also four blocks away, I sat on the floor and made pleasant conversation with my hostel-mate, a recent graduate from Taijung on a solo traveling adventure. She and I talked of careers, possibilities, pleasing others, customs, travel.
Four blocks away in exactly the same moments, nineteen people were murdered in two adjacent restaurants while probably having similar conversations. An unknown further number were injured or hospitalized.
What staggers me into bafflement is that the universe has space for these two completely different worlds to be happening simultaneously, in almost exactly the same place. I hardly know what to think. I'm reminded of Joyce's description of the sky as a "vast, indifferent dome," always there, forever silent.
I learned of the events early the following morning when the night-shift receptionist wouldn't allow me outside, as per the instructions of the television. There was no functioning bus or Metro currently, and impromptu refugee encampments had been set up around the city for the millions who couldn't make it home. After an hour I convinced the night guard to let me outside, and I went immediately to the intersection of Rue Bichat and Rue Alibert.
Initial reports state that only those at Le Petit Cambodge, a restaurant, were affected; that is incorrect. Le Carillon, the bar across the street, is just as rent with bullet holes and shattered glass. I arrived before police or news did. Sawdust had been laid down over the square to absorb the blood. There was punctured concrete from bullet strafing throughout the entire intersection, and splintered bicycles and motorcycles from the same. Blood pooled on the entry steps to Le Carillon, some of it gristly with the remains of flesh, elsewhere leaking into the crevices and gutters before anyone could bring flowers. It was still wet when I got there.
I was part of a very small group of strangers, and as light came to the morning so did more and more people, with their silences, roses, candles, cameras and consternation. We staggered around each other, stupid and raw. No matter what we did, or where we looked, at the evidence of violent death, at the spaces between each other, up to the unblinking sky... what was the name of this thing that had happened here, just a few hours ago?
Death disorients us because it is enormous. We're so good at focusing on what is small in life. This has significant and obvious dangers (not being thankful, namely), but I wonder if this tendency carries a silver lining. For it is only because of our amazing ability to forget how near death always is that we get anything done in life.
We get up in the morning and throw ourselves into matters of varying importance. We have some unique sense which lets us forget about imminent mortality as we continue the Search, the Great Search for happiness and meaning, the quest in which we do the dumbest and the smartest of things, feeling our way in the dark towards the answers.
Because the successes we find along the way are worth it, whether we live another hour, or for a hundred years.
---
Also: I was woken up this morning by none other than CNN, calling on behalf of my friends and family, asking if I was alive and unharmed. I am. Thank you ever so much for such an outpouring of concern. It means a tremendous deal. My heart goes out to- well, everyone, but especially those were happy before Friday Night, and cannot be now.
Information on the events and some of what we've been going through here.
---
Thoughts on the same, with hindsight: Paris, One Year Later: A Personal Perspective
Photographs of mine in the hours and days afterward: Death in Paris
We, your friends and co-workers are so very relieved that you are OK! And I am sure your family can now get some sleep!
Please stay safe ( no one wants to drive your work ;). )
I am sure there are already a few tongue - lashing waiting for you when you get home.
Peace!
Someone was joking about "building the world's biggest spanking machine" because of my off-the-gridness! Ha!
EXTREMELY happy to take my work off whatever poor board operator's hands as I head back into work tonight...
Thank you. It's you who are kind! Sometimes I think of the human organism as a collective, which encourages me because in that respect, it's remarkably resilient. to hear such an outpouring from so many caring people is beyond humbling. A friend pointed out that this type of coming together is perhaps the best outcome of an event like this.
your kindness is so great because it seems to come out of you so naturally, without you calculating it at all, like it's just your most normal way of operating. I wish everyone was like this. Thank you for such kind words.
I think of you every time I drive the bus near the Wing Luke (so, at least 4 times a day!). Thank you for being the compassionate being you are, and I'm glad you like the post. Still looking forward to lunch one of these days!
Great chatting the other day. It's only beginning to hit me now how great it is to be back here and specifically, still alive. I was less concerned about that over there, in the moment, as I feel good about the life I've lived, but to be back here in the company of my friends, et al reminds me that I do very much wish to continue spending time with these fine folks. There is more to be done.
We will all be glad to see you again never let the ugliness touch your heart peace
As all have already said, you are a light in the lives of many. Thank you for sharing your experiences and perspective.
Warmly, Holli
Please continue being the considerate, compassionate artist and human that you are. And thank you so much for always being so enthusiastic about sharing the blog!
Come home safe, friend. I am sorry your trip was marred by this unspeakable act. May it only build you as a better person.
Thank you, Jennie, for such eloquent words. I was less concerned about staying alive over there, during the event, perhaps because I feel I've lived well and I was alone. It's only been upon returning home and seeing my parents and dear friends that it's hit me how much I really would like to continue spending time with these people. There is more to be experienced, and shared, and accomplished.
I'm thankful for everything about the trip. It's given me a greater perspective... and hopefully a couple decent photos! Still waiting for the film to come back!
PS- Thanks for your help on the road during the craziness last night! Probably the first and last time I'll get to make a U-turn in the middle of Rainier in a bus! Fun!
I never imagined! I think of photography as being just as subjective an art form as painting, despite its documentary tendencies, and I only wonder what my photos will look like. More than anything my photos are generally pictures of what I'm feeling/thinking during the moment, or images of how I see something more than what it is, and as such I'm curious to see what the pictures are like, because they will be pictures of things I shot before I could process what I was looking at.
I'm so glad the post resonates. I still have trouble considering how to think about the incident. Someone told me, "to see it as surreal is our tool, a gift we've been given to get around processing it fully until we're ready."
Did you know Nathan was missing in Paris? Has anyone let Metro know, contacted his Chief?
I promptly called my Chief. Then spent the hours before the game walking around thinking Nathan....not Nathan.
Glad you're ok my friend. Hope you're considering the SIT recruitment.
I too am so thankful and grateful to be in one piece. It's beyond fantastic, really. Thanks for reading, and for your continued support!